Avoiding Hangover Hell
posted 02/06/2006
By Christine Haran
"I'll never drink again." It's a claim many of us have made the morning after
a debauched night while struggling to face the daylight with a pounding
headache, a parched tongue and a distinctly queasy feeling in the pit of the
stomach.
For many, this promise is short-lived and is particularly hard to maintain
during the holiday season. As Robert Swift, MD, a professor of psychiatry at
Brown University Medical School and associate chief of research at the
Providence VA Medical Center in Rhode Island, points out, people tend to
increase their alcohol consumption during the holidays when there are more
parties and people have more leisure time.
So if you've overindulged at the office holiday party, you might find
yourself not only deeply embarrassed but also seeking a quick hangover cure.
Hangover remedies abound and include such treats as anchovies, tea made from
rabbit droppings and, of course, another stiff drink. But do any of them work?
Below, Dr. Swift talks about what exactly causes a hangover, how best to
cope—and how to avoid such misery in the first place.
What is hangover?
Hangover is a "collection" of symptoms that occur after a bout of alcohol
drinking. It's that simple.
What predisposes some people to hangover?
There are some studies that suggest that there may be some genetic
predispositions to hangover, although that's not clear. Obviously, larger
quantities of alcohol are more likely to produce more severe hangovers. And
there are a lot of other factors that may go into it as well. There is some
evidence that the type of alcohol consumed may relate to hangover, the time of
day that the alcohol's consumed, whether one is drinking instead of sleeping,
whether you eat while you're drinking, and how well hydrated you are.
Can you give a sense of how many drinks are needed
over what period of time for an average person to end up with a hangover?
That's hard to know because it depends on a lot of factors, and it's an
individual sort of thing. There are people who are drink very, very heavily—who
are alcoholics—and never get a hangover and there are some who drink very
heavily and they do get hangovers
What the worse time of day to drink in terms of
hangover?
It's interesting. On the one hand, alcohol consumed in the morning tends to be
more intoxicating, believe it or not. But by and large, most people drink in the
evening and late at night, and that means that they may be drinking instead of
sleeping and alcohol influences the quality of sleep as well. As a result, one
ends up sleep deprived, and that can certainly exacerbate hangover symptoms.
Does body weight play a role?
Body weight will play a role in that it affects the concentration of alcohol and
other substances that ultimately get into your body. The concentration is
actually affected by the amount of water in your body, which is partially
dependent upon your weight but not entirely. When people do calculations of
alcohol—how much alcohol will it take to achieve to a certain blood alcohol
level—they look at what's called "lean body weight" because the alcohol doesn't
go into the fat. So a fat person isn't necessarily more resistant to the effect
of alcohol because they may have the same amount of body water as somebody who's
very skinny.
Men have more body water than women do, so if a man and a woman who weigh the
same drink the same quantity, the man will have a lower blood alcohol than the
woman will, because the woman has less body water to dissolve the alcohol.
What are some of the symptoms of hangover?
I think the predominant symptom of hangover is headache. Most people experience
a headache, and many experience some gastrointestinal symptoms, predominantly
nausea and sometimes vomiting. There's a sense of general malaise, of just not
feeling well, feeling like you're fatigued, can't concentrate. People's mouths
feel very dry because they're dehydrated.
What is happening in the body to cause these
symptoms?
That's still not entirely known. There are two major theories about the causes
of hangover. The first theory is the withdrawal theory, which suggests that
hangover is really a type of mild alcohol withdrawal. If you look at people's
brains in a brain wave machine, even though people may be feeling fatigued and
tired, their brain is actually stimulated. And that's what alcohol withdrawal
is: It's a hyperstimulatory state. Chronic alcoholics, if they stop drinking,
get anxious, they get excited, they can't sleep, they get the shakes. They may
even hallucinate. It's thought that even one bout of heavy drinking may induce a
state of kind of mild central nervous system excitation and people perceive that
as a hangover.
The second theory is that the hangover is due not to the alcohol per se but
other things in the alcohol, the so-called congeners. A beverage alcohol is
usually not 100 percent pure. For example, whiskey may be distilled, but then
it's stored in charred-oak barrels for years and years, so you get all of these
compounds that leach out of the barrels and then get degraded over time. There
are hundreds of biological compounds in alcohol beverages. Of course, with wine
and beer, you actually add yeast to the grapes or the malted barley or whatever,
so there are lots of chemicals in it.
The other thing is that the yeast also makes other kinds of alcohols. When
yeast ferments sugar and alcohol, the vast majority of what it makes is ethyl
alcohol, which is the alcohol we drink. But the yeast can also produce other
alcohols, such as smaller alcohols like methanol (or wood alcohol), and
methanol's pretty toxic. It can cause blindness, in fact, if you drink it pure.
When methanol is metabolized in the liver, it's converted to formaldehyde,
which is embalming fluid. So when you drink alcohol that contains some methanol,
your body first gets rid of the ethyl alcohol but the methanol stays in your
blood. It doesn't get degraded, and it actually builds up over time. Then when
you've burned up all the ethanol, you start to metabolize the methanol and
produce formaldehyde as a byproduct of that, and some people feel that produces
the symptoms.
Do certain types of alcohol beverages have more
methanol than others?
Yes. There appears to be a relationship between the likelihood of getting a
hangover and how dark the alcohol is. The color means that the alcohol has more
junk in it. The darker color is somehow reflecting the level of congeners. So
more clear-colored alcohols, like vodka and gin, are less likely to give you a
hangover than a darker-colored alcohol, like a whiskey or a scotch, bourbon or
brandy. Likewise, among wines, people often find they're more likely to get a
headache from red wine rather than white wine. Sulfites in red wine may
contribute to hangover in people who are sensitive to them.
How can people treat a hangover?
Prevention is best. Avoid alcohol and you won't get a hangover. Drinking in
moderation will also help. Mixing alcohol with other beverages, drinking slowly.
Drinking alcohol with food will reduce the concentration of alcohol in your
stomach. It will dilute it and be less irritating to the stomach. Also when
people drink and eat at the same time, less alcohol is absorbed into their blood
because the alcohol's absorbed more slowly and therefore more of it gets
metabolized by the liver and the stomach before it gets into the blood stream.
Why do some people argue that a drink in the morning
cures hangover?
The "hair of the dog that bit you"—a drink in the morning—might make you feel
better because you stop the metabolism of methanol and the formation of
formaldehyde because you've got alcohol in your system again. That could help
the withdrawal theory, too. If you are withdrawing from alcohol, so to speak,
you give yourself a little bit of alcohol to "detox" yourself.
If you have overindulged, are there any options?
If you have overindulged, remedies abound. I think for thousands of years
probably there have been reported remedies for hangover. But there really is
very little that has been scientifically proven to improve a hangover. In fact,
I don't know of anything.
So people should just treat their symptoms?
People should treat their symptoms, but even treating the symptoms can have side
effects. For example, if you have a headache, you can take an antiinflammatory
medication like aspirin or ibuprofen. But, those can be irritating to the
stomach, which has already been irritated from the night before. And after
you've been drinking a lot of alcohol, you should not take acetaminophen
(Tylenol) because it has some toxicity to the liver, which is actually magnified
by drinking alcohol. In fact, there have been questions about whether there
ought to be a warning on the label.
Rehydrating will help, though people aren't as dehydrated as much as they
feel dry. But actually drinking fluids, having some carbohydrate in case your
blood sugar's down, having something mild in the stomach if there's some stomach
irritation, is a good idea.
Is there anything good about a hangover?
The question that one could argue philosophically is that a hangover might be
good for you because it deters you from drinking too much the next time.